Oliver Wendell Holmes – Bad man theory

law articles for llm phd students

Bad-man theory is a jurisprudential doctrine or belief, according to which a bad person’s view of the law represents the best test of what exactly the law is because that person shall carefully and precisely calculate what the rules allow and operate up to the rules’ limits. This theory is also known as prediction theory.

This theory was first adopted by Oliver Wendell Holmes who mentioned that a society’s legal system is defined by predicting how the law affects a person, as opposed to considering the ethics or morals underlying the law.


Free Review Within 60 Days

Should your examiners request some changes, we will do so for you and for free!


Under this theory, the prediction is done by viewing the law in accordance with a bad man’s point of view who is not bothered about morals. Such a person is unconcerned with acting morally. Instead, such a person would be concerned about the degree of punishments certain acts will incur by the public force of law.

Holmes believed that the law should be defined as a prediction, most specifically, a prediction of how the courts behave. His rationale was based on an argument regarding the opinion of a “bad man.” Bad men, Holmes argued in his paper The Path of the Law, care little for ethics or lofty conceptions of natural law; instead they care simply about staying out of jail and avoiding paying damages. In Holmes’s mind, therefore, it was most useful to define “the law” as a prediction of what will bring punishment or other consequences from a court.

The theory played a key role in influencing American Legal Realism.

Holmes wrote that “a bad man has as much reason as a good one for wishing to avoid an encounter with the public force, and therefore you can see the practical importance of the distinction between morality and law”. Nearly every man wants to avoid the disagreeable consequences of disobeying the law, but not all want to obey the law only to obey it.

This is an extract from Holmes’ article The Path of the Law:

Take the fundamental question, What constitutes the law? You will find some text writers telling you that it is something different from what is decided by the courts of Massachusetts or England, that it is a system of reason, that it is a deduction from principles of ethics or admitted axioms or what not, which may or may not coincide with the decisions.

But if we take the view of our friend the bad man we shall find that he does not care two straws for the axioms or deductions, but that he does want to know what the Massachusetts or English courts are likely to do in fact. I am much of this mind. The prophecies of what the courts will do in fact, and nothing more pretentious, are what I mean by the law. (emphasis added)

Hart’s criticism of ‘bad man’ theory

HLA Hart criticized Holmes’ theory in his book The Concept of Law (1961). He argued that (1) it ignores the internal point of view towards law, the sense shared by officials and law-abiding citizens that rules of law `ought’ to be obeyed; (2) it undervalues “the ways in which the law is used to control, to guide, and to plan life out of court.” In other words, Holmes focused on law as it is used to solve disputes in court; (3) As for the `bad man’, Hart asks, “Why should not law be equally if not more concerned with the `puzzled man’ or `ignorant man’ who is willing to do what is required, if only he can be told what it is? Or with the `man who wishes to arrange his affairs’ if only he can be told how to do it?”

It is important to have an understanding of what the ‘bad man’ theory is all about. It’s also important to be able to criticize it – to say something about whether you agree with it.


 

Law articles for LLM and PhD students:

  1. Getting into a PhD program for law
  2. Tips on how to write a law thesis
  3. Academic proofreading thesis for LLM or a PhD in law
  4. Finishing your PhD thesis or LLM thesis
  5. How to start my Research Proposal
  6. How important is your thesis or dissertation to you?
  7. Proofreading Report help you to improve your writing
  8. Academic proofreading thesis for LLM or a PhD in law
  9. Want to pass or gain distinction?
  10. Achieving the dream of a postgraduate law degree